Disable Preloader

CaseLaw

Nkwocha V. Gov. Anambra State (1984) CLR 6(f) (SC)

Judgement delivered on June 28th 1984

Brief

  • Succession to property – rights of the state
  • Powers formally vested in State Military Governor
  • Revocation of leasehold interest

Facts

In the High Court of Justice, Anambra State, holden at Enugu, the plaintiff in this case instituted an action against the defendants wherein his claim is as follows -

  • 2.
    2. A declaration that the defendants have no right or power or competence to revoke the leasehold interests of the plaintiff in the said plots for the pur¬poses specified in the Revocation Notices dated 16th February, 1981 (Ref. No. LEN: 3007/215 and that the said leasehold interests are still subsisting."

The case went to trial and, at the address stage, Chief F.R.A. Williams (S.A.N.) learned counsel for the plaintiff, submitted that in the light of the pleadings, there had arisen substantial questions of law as regards the interpretation and applica-tion of some provisions of the Constitution that should warrant a reference to the Court of Appeal. The Attorney-General of Anambra State, who appeared for the defendants, opposed Chief Williams' application.

The learned trial Judge, who refused the application for reference to the Court of Appeal, proceeded with an examination of the case on its merit. He held, at the end of that examination, that the plaintiff failed to make out a case on the merit. He was also of the opinion that the case was not justiciable and the plaintiff's remedy, if any lay with the National Assembly.

The plaintiff, who was not satisfied with this decision, thereupon, appealed to the Court of Appeal, which referred the matter to the Supreme Court for determination.

  • 4.
    Debt of your discount-current account with Nkwo market community Bank with the sum being, payment for the up front interest at the rate of 5% consultancy, 1% legal and 1.5% processing fee.
  • 5.
    Failure to balance at month end shall be liable to 3% to penalty on 1st day of the new month 4% from 2nd and 15th and additional 3% after 15 of the month".

Issues

  • 1.
    Whether the Governor of Anambra State is the proper authority to...
    Read More